Oboe Redemption In D Minor and Other Moments of Musical Clarity


I owe the oboe an apology. Not just one singular, specific oboe, but all of oboekind. You see, in pursuit of the first requirement for the Music Appreciation badge, I started a listening log two months ago, tracking my thoughts on symphonic music. In one recent entry about Tomaso Albinoni’s “Oboe Concerto in G Min” I wrote: “This is too much oboe for me. Turns out, I’m not a big oboe person. Less oboe, please.”

Not shortly thereafter, I received a plea from a Twitter follower to reconsider this double reed woodwind (say that five times fast!), not just because his wife is an oboist, but also because he believes this classic instrument deserves some lovin’. He offered me some suggestions and after digging around, I found Bach’s “Oboe Concerto in D Minor” and have to concede the win to Mike K. Smith of South East Kent, UK due to the explicit pleasantness of that piece. You win, my man, as the oboe should not be judged on one composition alone, but rather, the quality of its contributions to music as a whole.

Mike also suggested some of Francis Poulenc’s works featuring the bassoon. The upside to watching this via YouTube rather than listening to it via iTunes is that I came to the shocking realization that until I pointed my browser to that video and watched that man blow into that excessively long reedish thing, I had no idea what a bassoon looked like.

To rectify my apparent instrumental ignorance, I decided to tackle requirement #2 of the Music Appreciation badge:

Listen to symphony orchestras at concerts or on the phonograph or radio. Collect pictures of instruments that are found in symphony orchestras. Show that you know what instruments are in each of the four choirs; how the characteristic sound in each choir is produced. If possible, look at the kind of score the conductor uses.

First of all, I thought to myself, What in the effing eff are the “four choirs”?!

Luckily, the interwebs – especially the fantastically useful corner occupied by Google Books – prove fruitful, as after some scouring I found these two texts that laid it out in early 20th century-speak for me:

Reading Lessons in Music Appreciation: Aids In Preparation of Students for Music Memory Contest of The Interscholastic League Division, published by The University of Texas (1922)

What We Hear In Music: A Course of Study in Music History and Appreciation for use in The Home, Music Clubs, Conservatories, High Schools, Normal Schools, Colleges and Universities, written by Anne Shaw (1913)

In a nutshell, a symphony orchestra has four groupings (or “choirs”): strings, woodwinds, brasses, and percussion. 18th century Austrian composer Franz Joseph Haydn was the first to divvy up his orchestra in this way, earning him the title “Father of the Symphony.” Impressive, especially since my only current distinction is “Mother of the Hundred-Pound Cat-Beast.”

Now, for my sake and yours, let’s break down these choirs into actual pictures of actual instruments so as to avoid any future instances of gross embarrassment. The Oregon Symphony has an awesome primer on their website describing the sections of an orchestra, if you’re looking for a bit more oomph here.


STRINGS (1st choir): Violin, viola, cello, bass, harp

These are the sounds you’ll hear front and center in most symphonies (they’ve definitely dominated the selections I’ve been listening to for this project) and they’re usually grouped around the conductor. These are played with a bow and by plucking.


WOODWINDS (2nd choir): Flute, oboe, English horn, clarinet, bassoon, piccolo

Wouldn’t you know it, the oboe is the star player here – it usually sits in the middle of the section and is the guiding star on pitch for all other instruments in its section. These are played by blowing into them and covering up holes to create different sounds.

BRASSES (3rd choir): Trumpet, French horn, trombone, tuba

This is the loudmouth section of the symphony – these instruments produce big, deep, bellowing sounds. These are played by blowing into them, creating vibrations with your mouth, and covering up holes as above.


PERCUSSION (4th choir): Timpani, drums, triangle, bell, cymbals, xylophone

As with most rock bands, these are usually shoved to the back of the room – even in classical music, drummers never get any respect. These are played by striking, shaking, and scraping.

Thank you, Encyclopedia Britannica, for making the whole “collect pictures” thing a lot easier on me. Note to readers: the photo at the top is a selection of my personal percussion arsenal (minus my entire drum kit). Yes, that cowbell reads “MORE.”  


  1. I always wondered how they paired kids up with instruments in school. The drummers in our section were always ruckus-makers. Were they this way and the drums chose them, or did they choose the drums? The horn sections always enjoyed emptying their spit valves on each other or on the floor. I was given the clarinet. I was never super into it, but I wish I’d made it sound better. I appreciate and respect people that can play woodwinds, especially double-reeds like the oboe and bassoon, and make them sound beautiful, instead of squawky like most of us did in high school. I also never paid attention to most of this, or was unaware of it in high school. I just played what and when I was told. So it’s nice to have an overview of what I was actually doing.

  2. “Were they this way and the drums chose them, or did they choose the drums?” Chicken or egg? And great question! I always liked to sing when I was a kid, so I was in choir – I didn’t play any instruments until I picked up the guitar in grad school, mostly as a way to impress a guy I had a crush on. Instead, I sucked at the guitar and gravitated to the drums after hearing Sleater-Kinney’s ‘One Beat’ for the first time. Mysteries of the universe!

  3. […] Oboe Redemption In D Minor and Other Moments of Musical Clarity […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: